Monday, March 5, 2012

Creepy Peter

I just finished the book Peter Pan by J. M. Barrie.  A mischievous boy who can fly, and magically refuses to grow up, Peter Pan spends his never-ending childhood adventuring on the small island of Neverland as the leader of his gang, The Lost Boys. They all interact with mermaids, natives, fairies, pirates, and from time to time, meeting ordinary children from the outside world.  The story is about how Peter meets a young girl named Wendy, and her two brothers, John, and Michael.  Peter brings the children to Neverland one night when their parents are out, and their aunt is babysitting.  On the surface it seems like an ordinary children’s book, but when you look deeper it is so much more.  It is the story of a kidnapping and Stockholm Syndrome, two very adult issues.
        The story of Peter Pan is dominated by a kidnapping.  While it may appear that the children go to Neverland willingly, you can also interpret it as Peter kidnapping Wendy, John, and Michael.  The point at which the kidnapping occurs is when Peter sneaks into their home and takes them to an unknown world, Neverland.  He comes in and tells them all about Neverland and about how amazing it is, in order to make them want to come, and leave their life in London behind.  Peter only tells of the good things, never the bad.  Wendy hesitates.  She doesn’t want to leave her whole life behind just to live in Neverland.  But, Peter entices her to come with tales of mermaids, which Wendy loves.  There is no need to change the boys’ opinions, for they are already packing to leave. Peter is very good at persuading and seducing people; he is very convincing.  Another example is that Peter has this troupe of “Lost Boys” and they are all orphans, but orphans or not, they were kidnapped, by Peter Pan.  The story goes to say that the boys fell out of their perambulators as babies, Peter took the boys and raised them as his family.  I think that all Peter wants is to have a family.  That is the reason that he took the boys, and enticed Wendy to come and be their mother.  Even if his motives are innocent, Peter is a kidnapper to satisfy his emotional needs.
    The story of Peter Pan is actually very dark.  The children even develop a syndrome known as Stockholm Syndrome.  Stockholm Syndrome is when a person who is kidnapped begins to feel compassion for their kidnappers.  For instance, when Wendy is about to leave Neverland, she turns back, right before she leaves and looks at Peter sadly.  Through the story, Wendy begins to love Peter, even though he kidnapped her.  Another aspect of Stockholm Syndrome is when you almost forget who you really are.  In the story, John and Michael forget their old life.  They start to think of Wendy as their real mother, and forget their actual mother and their actual home.  A large part of Peter Pan is about Stockholm Syndrome.
    Peter Pan is a very dark, and deep story.  There are many ways to look at it.  It can be about a child, who never wants to grow up, or about a young kidnapper.  It’s very creepy, and odd.  It is not only a children’s book, the underlying story is scary.  I think that the story of Peter Pan can be related to the story of Patty Hearst, both include girls who were kidnapped and developed love to their kidnappers, except, Patty’s story is REAL!

7 comments:

  1. Wow, I haven't read Peter in so long! When I was younger I always thought about the book as a very happy story. Now that I read your blog post, I am convinced that it isn't! You are very persuasive. Saying that, this honestly makes me kind of sad! (In a good way!)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Haha! I did too! Then when I read it this time around, looking with this more adult eye, I saw just how odd it truly was! I'm glad I persuaded you, but I'm sorry you're sad "(in a good way)"!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Incredible work, Delia. I didn't think that unpacking texts and stories can go this far! It really brings me back to when we wrote the forwards to our pictures books. You should really look into why the book was written because I'm really curious to know if there was indeed, a hidden meaning!

    ReplyDelete
  4. That is a very interesting way to look at what is thought to be a very innocent story. I am not sure if that's the way the author intended it, but it is a very deep, thought provoking theory. This really made me think about other story's that are thought to be fun and not serious, although after reading this, I am starting to think otherwise about them.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Whoa, now that's a different take on it... Although this definitely puts Peter Pan is a kind of bad light, I think it's fascinating how you were able to take a children's fairytale (for lack of better words), and write about a very dark and unusual theme. You clearly unpacked the text very well, and I think it's great that you looked at the story with a whole different perspective. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I never really thought of Peter Pan that way! (Stockholm syndrome didn't even top the list.)
    I agree with everyone that you did unpack your text, but I also think that, like Leo, the author didn't intend for the story to be that way.
    It's as if your saying that Cinderella is about a girl with a abusive family and an arranged marriage.
    It is, after all, a children's fairy tale, but you have lots of textual evidence to make it seem more different than what the traditional 'Peter Pan' story means to most people.
    Other than that, great job!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I didn't either Maimuna! However, many people do think that fairy tales like jack and the beanstalk, little red riding hood, and even Cinderella have very dark subliminal messages. People believe that through these stories children were meant to learn a lesson. I think that peter pan may have not consciously been written about this very dark concept, but it still sends a strong message. J.M Barrie may have meant to write a innocent fairy tale like you say, but he ended up with a very very adult idea hidden under that childish exterior. The truth is that no matter if the writer intended it or not, many people see these hidden meanings as lessons to learn. In my research some are outlandish and somewhat ridiculous, but every story should teach a lesson or have an impact on the reader, maybe these hidden messages are the lessons and morals for these stories.

    ReplyDelete